Skip to content
Story Expansion

Were there women pirates? Of course. The Hidden Heroines of the High Seas

Were there women pirates?

Stories of women pirates often begin with Anne Bonny and Mary Read, then disappear into a fog of aliases, borrowed anecdotes and invention. Look further and the picture widens: an Irish maritime leader negotiating with a queen; a Swedish privateering entrepreneur managing ships and property; a Chinese leader navigating the rivalries of a vast confederation. Their lives were not interchangeable, and neither were the evidence and legends that survive them.


For more information on The Charm of Hope check out the production’s official page.



Grace O’Malley: Ireland’s Pirate Queen

Before the Caribbean pirates of popular memory, Grace O’Malley (Gráinne Ní Mháille) exercised power along the Irish coast. A seafarer and leader in a family with maritime interests, she defended her position amid conflict with other Irish families and English authorities. She met Queen Elizabeth I in 1593; the Mayo County Council historical survey records the meeting. Stories about their encounter have acquired embellishments, and details such as a supposed permission to wear armour should not be mistaken for established fact.

O’Malley belonged to a different time and political world from the Caribbean pirates who became famous more than a century later. Calling her a pirate queen captures something of her reputation, but it can also flatten the tangled loyalties, coastal trade and conflicts over Irish land and authority in which she acted.

Anne Bonny and Mary Read

Anne Bonny and Mary Read sailed with John “Calico Jack” Rackham’s crew in the Caribbean and were captured in 1720. Their stories illustrate the blurred line between history and romance: much of the vivid account of their early lives and clothing comes from Charles Johnson’s 1724 A General History of the Pyrates. Royal Museums Greenwich notes both the uncertainty of that source and disagreement about whether Read joined the crew disguised as a man.

Johnson’s account depicts Bonny and Read fighting during the crew’s capture while others remained below deck. It is a memorable scene, but the book is a narrative source with disputed accuracy, not an independently confirmed transcript of everything said or done. Its authorship has also been debated; an attribution to Daniel Defoe is not established.

After their capture, Bonny and Read were tried in Jamaica and obtained delays of execution on grounds of pregnancy. Read died in prison in 1721; Bonny’s subsequent fate is uncertain. Their reported last stand is vivid, but it does not establish every detail of their clothing, weapons or relationships, nor does it tell us that every crewmate treated them equally.

Stories of women adopting men’s clothing at sea raise questions about access, identity and practical clothing, but not every colourful biography can be verified. The stories attached to figures such as Jacquotte Delahaye circulate in later retellings; their details need stronger evidence before being presented as fact. Royal Museums Greenwich notes that practical seagoing clothing need not prove an attempt to conceal a person’s sex.

Crossdressing and Comradeship

Johnson’s narrative offers reasons for Read’s use of men’s clothing, including opportunities for work and military service. Those episodes should be attributed to the book rather than treated as a memoir written by Read herself. The record leaves room for questions about motives that she cannot now answer for us.

Carrying a weapon or working on deck did not make Bonny and Read men; it shows women acting in a maritime world usually described through men. A dramatic account of a battle cannot tell us exactly what every crewmate thought of them, or settle the private relationships that later stories have invented.

Accounts of Bonny’s association with Rackham, and of her marriage to James Bonny, are also entangled with Johnson’s narrative. The surviving story is intriguing enough without claiming to know the private motives of everyone involved. What is clearer is that she was among Rackham’s crew when they were captured.

Pirate Queens of the World

Other names circulate at the edge of the record. Charlotte de Berry and Jacquotte Delahaye appear in popular accounts, but their dramatic biographies are difficult to substantiate in contemporary records. A compelling story is worth examining; its repetition alone does not turn it into a documented life.

In North America, Rachel Wall’s name appears in accounts of eighteenth-century New England piracy. The U.S. National Park Service discusses her life and the printed confession associated with her execution in Boston in 1789. Such accounts invite careful reading: a dramatic reported confession or later retelling is not the same as independent proof of every raid and killing attributed to her.

In the South China Sea, Zheng Yi Sao, also known as Cheng I Sao or Ching Shih, became a powerful leader of a pirate confederation. After her first husband Zheng Yi died in 1807, she consolidated her position alongside Cheung Po Tsai; the Hong Kong heritage survey discusses the confederation and its fleet. She and Cheung Po Tsai accepted Qing surrender terms in 1810. Estimates of ships and people vary between accounts, and impressive round numbers should not be treated as precise counts.

Less familiar names pose a challenge for the same reason. Accounts of Mrs. Beare, Maria Lindsey and Martha Farley need stronger, identifiable contemporary evidence before their supposed raids, marriages or trial outcomes can be confidently retold. Their presence in a list of pirates is a starting point for research, not proof of the details attached to them.

In Sweden, Ingela Gathenhielm helped run a privateering enterprise and continued it after her husband Lars died in 1718. The Swedish biographical dictionary of women documents her business and property management and her death in 1729. Privateering involved a commission from a state; whether a particular act was lawful could still be contested, but the terms “privateer” and “pirate” are not interchangeable.

Partners and Plunderers

Women’s maritime lives were often recorded through a husband, father or colleague. That can obscure their own work, as in the management of a privateering business, while also making it tempting to invent motives to fill the silence. Family ties mattered, but they do not by themselves explain a person’s decisions.

Stories of other women accused of piracy or connected to pirate crews deserve the same caution. An unsourced anecdote about a trial, a confession or a marriage should not be converted into a certain biography. Court documents, shipping records and contemporary testimony can help where they survive, although each has its own perspective.

Pirate legends also travel into fiction. In Lunny’s historical panorama, a sloop called Innocent Vultures cruises the world; its captain, Andrew Swallow, even finds himself fraternizing with a band of Innocent Vultures Pirate Crew, which includes women both fierce and rueful (this is fictional, but a nod to history’s hard-living mariners). The author Hugo Lunny draws explicitly on real tales: publicity notes for The Charm of Hope mention that pirates like Anne Bonny and Calico Jack inspired their fictional crew.[20] In one telling modern pastiche, these myths end up mashed with more recent Americana—for instance, Jackalopes (the horned jackrabbit of folklore) become an “exotic meat” served at Knight’s Deli as a whimsical footnote in Castigation. These absurd details underscore how far our legends have drifted from the facts: a cute Jackalope steak or made-up name like Bonnie Kidd only highlight that we still hunger for more pirate lore.

The outcomes varied. Read died in prison; Bonny’s later life remains uncertain. O’Malley’s authority was bound up with the conflicts and politics of her coast, while Zheng Yi Sao negotiated a surrender to the Qing authorities in 1810. Pregnancy delayed the executions of Bonny and Read; the record does not justify dismissing that claim as a routine deception.

Legend vs. Record

To separate document from drama, ask what kind of source is being used and how close it is to the events. Johnson’s popular pirate history is an early narrative, not an infallible witness. Court records can establish particular proceedings without revealing a whole life, while folklore can show how a reputation grew even when its details cannot be confirmed.

The gaps should not erase women from maritime history, nor should the desire for a satisfying story fill every silence with certainty. The evidence supports different kinds of participation: sailing with a crew, managing a privateering enterprise, commanding through alliances, and defending coastal interests. Those roles belong to distinct places and periods.

Modern retellings often swing between romantic heroines and sensational villains. Both can obscure the conditions of a voyage and the people harmed by raids. A more interesting account gives each woman room to act within her own circumstances while acknowledging what the surviving sources cannot tell us.

These women are more compelling as individuals than as identical icons of freedom. Some exercised inherited or negotiated authority; others entered stories of piracy through circumstances recorded only in partial and often hostile accounts. Their histories invite curiosity about power, danger and survival, without promising that the archive can answer every question.


Also, don’t forget to check out “The Charm of Hope” Behind The Screenplay page for more information on the writing inspiration and process.


The readers' conversation

What stayed with you?

Discuss the story. Respect the people here. Label spoilers and keep them out of opening lines. Comments are reviewed before publication on reader discussion posts.

Join the conversation

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Published by Broken English.