What exactly is “gallows humor”?
For more information on The Charm of Hope check out the production’s official page.
Gallows humor is, in a sense, laughter’s darkest triumph—humor that snickers at death and disaster. Merriam-Webster defines it plainly as “humor that makes fun of a life-threatening, disastrous, or terrifying situation”[1]. In practice it is an outlaw genre: jokes or witticisms born in the black pits of fear, delivered by those “facing a perfectly hopeless situation” who nevertheless “still manage to say something funny,” as Kurt Vonnegut observed[2]. It sits at the bleeding edge of taste, where levity collides head-on with tragedy. In literature and criticism it goes by many names—black comedy, dark humor—but gallows humor is specifically humor about the gallows, about execution and death. It differs from cruder “blue” or ribald jokes by a narrow definition: it treats mortality itself as the punchline. Even Wikipedia notes that while black humor spans many taboos, gallows humor is used “more specifically in relation to death, or situations that are reminiscent of dying”[3]. In other words, gallows jokes are not just irreverent: they are irreverent about the irreparable. It is the dissonance of cracking wise in the jaws of doom that gives gallows humor its grim subversive power.
Section Index
In etymology it is straightforwardly grim. The term appears in print in the early 20th century (Merriam notes its first use around 1901[4]), and its origins are literal: the gallows being the scaffold where condemned prisoners were hanged. To joke about one’s gallows, or to laugh at some other’s impending doom, was an act of resistance to fate. The surrealists later popularized a broader category (André Breton’s humour noir), but even Breton credited Jonathan Swift as a forefather of the form. (Think Swift’s A Modest Proposal, which makes the unthinkable act of cannibalism horrifyingly funny—exactly what Swift meant by reverse satire.) In long memory there are darker precursors: the ancient Greek jokes about crucifixion, Rabelais’s obscene excesses, even Dante’s sinners flipping the finger at God. The Roman tradition held Saint Lawrence up as the patron of sardonic wit: he quipped to his executioners “Turn me over—I’m done on this side” as he was burned alive[5]. (In art he is often depicted smiling on a gridiron.) In these and other origin myths, gallows humor is defiantly at odds with its setting: laughter from the lips of the dying.
Historical Examples: Holocaust and Soviet Union
Vonnegut’s echo of Freud on gallows humor is telling: he traced it to Central Europe, to “the peasants’ revolt, the thirty years’ war, and [the Napoleonic] wars”—centuries of bloody upheaval where only absurd jokes kept people sane[2]. He notes that in Eastern Europe, families joked even in concentration camps and sieges. “Jewish jokes,” he said, are often middle-European gallows jokes. Indeed the Holocaust produced countless such cracks. Viktor Frankl, in Man’s Search for Meaning, observed that even in Auschwitz prisoners would laugh—”Humor was another of the soul’s weapons in the fight for self-preservation”[6]. The infamous camp joke has a camp inmate asking, “When they turn me into soap, at least I will smell good,” or “Hey, see you on the same shelf!”—witticisms born of rumor and horror. Frankl recounted how his transport was diverted away from the feared Mauthausen camp; the men “danced with joy” in the train carriages when they realized they were going to Dachau instead (where, it turned out, there was no crematorium)[7]. “They laughed and cracked jokes in spite of, and during, all we had to go through.” For Frankl, this was not madness but strategy: “An abnormal response to an abnormal situation is in the nature of normal behavior”[8]. By laughing at the void, victims could briefly lighten the load of terror.
This lesson recurs throughout history and geography. In the Soviet Union under Stalin, telling a funny story could be literally suicidal—yet jokes spread like spores in the dark. Even the archivists knew it: diaries and samizdat regale us with anekdoty (short jokes) in which gulag-bound peasants outwit the authorities. One anecdote from the 1930s—later cited by reformer Gorbachev—has a terrified peasant yank Stalin from drowning, only to beg the despot not to reward him: “Just please don’t tell anyone I saved you!”[9]. Another poked fun at rapid Soviet industrialization: asked why modernization was so relentless, a Bolshevik pointed to a dozen trams and boasted there’d be hundreds soon. The peasant, returning to his village, showed that instead. He waved at a dozen graves and deadpanned, “You see those dozen graves? After five years, there will be thousands”[10]. The joke is macabre, counting corpses instead of cars—but its effect was electric: it made the terrible real and communal, momentarily relieving the silent fear. As Waterlow observed, even Gorbachev later noted: “The jokes always saved us”[11]. Laughing at Stalin might have landed a man in a gulag, but not laughing risked madness.
Wartime Trenches and Military Humor
In wartime trenches the pattern is eerily similar. The British Wipers Times—a satirical newspaper secretly published by soldiers at Ypres (known in Tommy-speak as “Wipers”)—brimmed with gallows humor. It lampooned the war with parody ads, poems, and editorials, classified without apology as trench humor. As one reviewer notes, its pages overflow with “gallows humor, tongue-in-cheek humor, black humor”[12]. Soldiers told dirty limericks about shell holes and barbed wire; they personified artillery shells as dinner guests and dubbed the 5th Blood Botany Department. The motto was always the same: if death is chasing you through the mud, try to trip it by laughing. (Decades later, sitcoms like M*A*S*H and novels like Catch-22 would memorialize this style.) More recently, in conflicts from Vietnam to Iraq, troops have sent home gruesome postcards (“Wish you were here—get the point?”) and spun yarns about miraculous survival. Photographs of makeshift signs—”I got the bullet to prove it!”—attest to an instinct passed down through militaries.
Medical Professionals and Emergency Responders
Indeed in every theater of cruelty—wars, gulags, terror camps, even hospital halls—gallows humor serves as a pressure valve. There is a reason it turns up in medical wards and fire stations as often as on battlefields. Physicians witness more pain and death than any layman should. Dr. Jeffrey Segal notes that in surgery, ERs, and ICUs one hears sly quips about comatose patients, a sudden discovery of an unexpected disorder, or a bizarre emergency. (“The good news for this patient,” one surgeon quipped, “is that he will have a disease named after him”—or in another, “The bad news is we can’t remove the vibrator from his rectum without surgery; the good news is we can change the batteries.”) Such jokes are told about patients, never to patients, yet they abound. As Segal writes, this gallows humor is “grim and ironic… in a desperate and hopeless situation”[13]. Nurses and doctors often regard it as a safety valve—blowing off steam, sharing a dark moment of camaraderie, staving off burnout[14]. Clinical studies confirm it is ubiquitous: emergency nurses routinely use black humor to “mitigate effects of critical incidents,” easing grief and helplessness[15]. Medical ethicists debate its propriety, but most agree: as long as the patient is not involved, such jokes can help the healer remain human. (One mediating psychiatrist quipped, “Joking about death fits the term most literally, but making fun of life-threatening… situations fits the category as well”[16].) In these enclosed worlds—ERs, barracks, bombed-out villages—silence is unbearable, so people trade in terrified laughter.
Political Resistance and Oppression
That laughter matters is evident in places of oppression. Gallows humor can mutate into political resistance. When totalitarian rulers forbid dissent, a joke becomes the stealth sabotage of power. Burhan Sönmez, a Turkish novelist, vividly illustrates this: his characters are prisoners who survive torture by telling each other funny stories. “Even though they are being tortured… on the borderline of death,” he writes, “the characters always try to find a way to laugh… We can resist any kind of evil in this world by laughing or telling a funny story. It protects us against evil and death”[17]. In a Guernica interview, Sönmez bluntly explains: “Laughter is something we have against oppression and oppressive people. Dictators hate people who laugh at them… If you create jokes against [them]… then they feel helpless and desperate”[18]. In other words, gallows humor becomes not just coping but a weapon: it undermines fear and authority by showing the oppressor cannot stop the joke.
This dynamic plays out in occupied territories and conflict zones today. Palestinians under Israeli occupation, for example, have turned grim reality into gallows humor as a form of resistance. Refugee camp anecdotes and online satire abound: one popular rib tells of an IDF patrol who nicknames their Humvee a “BMW,” to which a Palestinian prisoner quips “I feel like I’m riding in a BMW”—a dig at the absurdity of privilege and oppression. Dozens of Middle Eastern satirical websites (like Palestine’s Al-Hudood) publish headlines such as “Whitewashing Occupation Atrocities Added to Prerequisites for Miss Universe” or “Israel Welcomes Anhar al-Deek’s Newborn with a Baby-Sized Prison Jumpsuit.” The punchline is always double-edged: truth under veil of irony. As one commentator noted, “The worse the situation… the more Palestinians seek refuge in humor… laughing under occupation is a form of resistance”[19]. Laughing at drones, at blockades, at body searches—it affirms humanity when everything else dehumanizes.
Across the Israeli-Palestinian divide, gallows humor is common (the jokes cut both ways), but context shifts the impact. Israelis have their own darkly funny tropes: Mizrahi sufganiyot (doughnuts) jokes in Gaza offensives, or the aphoristic soldier quips (“In Gaza, we call firefights ‘just another barbeque'”). In Syria and Iraq, it surfaces in memes mocking ISIS absurdity (“ISIS recruits are told Paradise is full—please return later”). In Lebanon or Iran, humorist filmmakers and cartoonists have long ridiculed war and repression, even at great personal risk. (Iranian cybercomedy, for instance, thrives in clandestine Telegram groups.) In each culture, gallows humor signals: We are still alive, and by God, we will laugh.
The Ethics of Gallows Humor
This brings up the thorny ethics of gallows humor. Mustering laughter at tragedy is inherently fraught. Outsiders often wince—consider the public backlash when non-Jewish comedians crack Holocaust jokes, or when Twitter comedians joke about natural disasters. Holocaust scholars caution that only those who have lived through atrocity have moral license to laugh at it[20]. Similarly, a soldier jokes of shrapnel at home may amuse fellow veterans but fluster a civilian. Critics argue gallows humor can “trivialize” suffering or feel like a cruel mockery if misdirected. For example, barbed comic books or memes that mock refugee boats or death camps provoke outrage; the victims themselves often find them hurtful, the powerful find them threatening. But defenders counter that this raw humor is exactly what help victims survive, and that laughter bafflingly exposes reality quicker than sadness. As the scholar George Saunders put it, “Humor is what happens when we’re told the truth quicker and more directly than we’re used to. The comic is the truth stripped of the habitual, the cushioning, the easy consolation”[21]. In other words, gallows humor cuts through our polite buffers and forces an often brutal truth into plain sight—which can offend, but also enlighten.
Psychological Function and Coping Mechanism
Psychologists say gallows humor works like an emotional first-aid. Studies in high-stress professions show it temporarily releases tension, lets people reclaim agency, and saves face among peers[22][23]. Northwestern bioethicist Katie Watson notes that while outright expressions of fear or grief can look like weakness, gallows jokes are accepted—a socially permissible vent for fear[23]. Freud speculated that to the unterrified outsider, hearing the victim joke “relieves us of the burden of sympathy,” and to the victim it “avoids dealing with both internal… and external… conflicts,” redirecting them into laughter[24]. Viktor Frankl agreed: humor was a life-raft in concentration camps[6]. Even beyond war zones, Americans during the COVID-19 pandemic, for instance, unleashed a torrent of gallows memes: grinning skeletons with rollie-pollie charsets, and punchlines like “Day 400 of quarantine and I’ve just discovered my cat has legs.” To mental health counselors, these “depression memes” on Reddit were not mere edgelord nihilism but a collective coping mechanism. One psychologist told Arizona State students that today’s youth use fatalistic internet jokes much like previous generations used gallows humor to cope with trauma[25]. The ASU interviewer explained that on death row, prisoners making ironic last quips were doing exactly this same “rapid-truthing”—they faced the abyss and made it laugh[26][21]. The line between a Conrad story and a Twitter meme can blur: gallows humor adapts to each medium.
Cultural Expressions and Art Forms
Indeed, gallows humor has transformed across art forms and cultures. In literature it runs from Swift and Voltaire to Céline and Kharms; in theater from Marlowe’s Lucian calls for war to Beckett’s absurd clowning at extinction. In film and TV we’ve seen Dr. Strangelove, South Park, Black Mirror episodes and dark cartoons laugh at nuclear annihilation and social collapse. On stage, absurdist plays juggle jokes about plague and cannibalism as existential commentary. In every era, comedians test the limits: during 9/11, some risked offending by joking about falling bodies or the twin towers—a humor only a few dared, and many condemned, yet instantly memorable. Online, new subcultures—think the “dank meme” communities on Reddit and 4chan—revel in crude jokes about terrorism, disease, or school shootings. They posture as “edgelords,” but ultimately they are pushing against despair with one hand, chuckling at taboo with the other. As the death of comedian Jimmy Carr (who joked that the Romani Holocaust was a “positive”) proved, however, such jokes can be explosive. Once the audience is not “in” on the joke, the comedian can become “the executioner,” no longer a gallows wit but the victim of outrage.
By contrast, when done by those under fire, these jokes often feel vital and human. As Holocaust researcher Chaya Ostrower put it, humor in camps was a defense mechanism that “helped to endure” the absurd cruelty[27]. Concentration-camp archives show scores of Jewish jokes about Hitler and death, often self-deprecating, as if to say: “They can kill our bodies, but not our wit.” The paradox is stark but real: laughter is born amid pain. Philosopher Camus argued that in face of the absurd, a rebel must imagine Sisyphus happy—finding meaning through struggle. Perhaps gallows humor is the comedic sister to that rebellion. When life has lost all meaning, funny demands we make meaning—even if twisted—by mocking oblivion.
Not every joke is free of harm. Catholic doctrine once forbade smiling at one’s own execution, deeming it sinful. Modern debates swirl: Is it respectful or profane when, say, a doctor jokes about euthanasia? Or when a child cracks wise at a funeral? Context is everything. One ethicist warns that hurtful “callous humor” among coworkers can undermine trust if a patient overhears[28]. But exceptions are regular: emergency responders cringe if civilians catch them joking about a grisly crash. Most practitioners say the humor stays in-house.
Perhaps the power of gallows humor lies in its essential contradiction. It is both devilish and defiant. At its darkest, it trivializes terror (one might say insults the devil); at its most noble, it asserts the irrepressible spirit of the teller. The same joke that makes one listener recoil can make another breathe a shuddering sigh of relief. Victor Frankl put it starkly: a prisoner who could find a moment of levity in Auschwitz refused to surrender “for even one minute” to the enemy[6]. In a tortured Turkish cell, Sönmez’s characters know “it’s the only protection we have against… an oppressive government”[17]. On a gallows scaffold, the condemned quip may erase fear until one last breath. To spit in the face of death is to declare: You will not break me.
Also, don’t forget to check out “The Charm of Hope” Behind The Screenplay page for more information on the writing inspiration and process.
